verification is not a recommendation. it means the evidence standard has been met, nothing more, still working it out
#vendor-verification 2025-08-15
- truncation_tru — verification has never been for sale and never will be. offers get posted publicly with the sender redacted 14:16
- chlorhex — we have never revoked on a single result. we have revoked on a pattern i have watched this standard hold for three years including when it was inconvenient for a… 17:19
- chlorhex — slightly off topic but is the verification log the same thing as a recommendation 17:51
two labs a point or two apart on one lot is normal. both go in the log with both numbers
verification has never been for sale and never will be. offers get posted publicly with the sender redacted
a referral link is disqualifying because it makes the reporter an interested party. that is all
what counts: an independent report, on a lot you bought yourself, with the lot number, from a lab the room recognises
has anyone ever offered to pay for verification
a good result with bad sample handling gets logged with a note about the handling. context is part of the record
i have watched this standard hold for three years including when it was inconvenient for a popular supplier
update from 7 months ago: ERP added evidence and the entry now reflects it
pattern not one result
refresh on evidence
we have never revoked on a single result. we have revoked on a pattern
i have watched this standard hold for three years including when it was inconvenient for a popular supplier
what does not count: the supplier certificate alone, a screenshot, a referral link, or a friend who says it was fine
a lot number mismatch between the vial and the certificate is a serious finding. post it with photos of both
if you want to help, buy a lot, test it, and post the report with the lot number. that is the whole contribution
somebody once offered to fund the testing programme in exchange for an entry. the offer is in the log, not advice obviously
slightly off topic but is the verification log the same thing as a recommendation
nothing gets deleted from the log, including our own mistakes