vialroom
Thread · #vendor-verification · 2025-06-04

what does evidence added, status unchanged actually mean in practice

Spun off from a message in #vendor-verification on 2025-06-04. 16 messages, 3 participants.

The message this came from
  • stack_sceptic — what does evidence added, status unchanged actually mean in practice, anyone 20:11
NE

verification here means a documented chain, not a badge, and the room has never issued a badge, chronological, oldest first

🙏11
RT

standards question what actually counts as evidence for this log and what does not

💀18

verification question if the evidence is thin the entry says the evidence is thin. that is more useful than a score, nothing gets deleted

NE

a photograph adds provenance and nothing about purity. it is worth having and it is not evidence of a number

🧊5👍1
RT

chain is incomplete on this one verification is not a recommendation. it means the evidence standard has been met, nothing more

🙏5💀11
SS

how do you handle a result that is good but the sample handling was poor

NE

what counts: an independent report, on a lot you bought yourself, with the lot number, from a lab the room recognises

SS

correcting my own earlier entry the suppliers in the directory all have a clean log. that is what having a source file means here